Project Challenge: Audi "Rubix"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=AFHk3JU_pcs

In this project challenge I'm going to cover my experience working on a commercial for Audi. At the time of writing this the commercial was not released and I do not have a link to it. Hopefully I'll get a link sometime soon after its release. You have to see it to appreciate it I think.

In this commercial we were asked to do every raytracers worst nightmare. Create a photo-real 9x9x9 glass rubix cube full of car parts in a photo-real CG environment. Then animate the cube rotating around and assembling the car as it spins until the car is completely built. For anyone keeping score...A 9x9x9 grid of boxes means that we had 729 cubes, each with at least one object inside it and most of them having several objects. Each individual cube had realistically modeled sides made of glass, which means we were seeing through a minimum of 36 panes and even more if viewing from an angle. So...729 cubes, made of 6 objects each. At least 3 times as many part objects. That put us at 26,244 nodes, just for the geometry of the cube and parts. Once you throw in the nodes for the environment and cube rig I can't even come up with that number...but these were some HUGE files to work in. Probably the most complex I've ever worked with.

When the project began I was one of the first modelers/lighters to start on it. There was a lot of uncertainty about what the environment should be like. It needed to not distract from the cubes, but also look good in its own right. Myself and two other lighters modeled up rough environments with temp glass cubes in it every day for a week or two. All similar but also quite different. As things progressed the environments that kept getting the most response were the very simple plain white rooms. In the beginning these all had white artificial lighting and no natural light sources. We went this direction for a long time, but when you put a glass cube in an evenly lit white room it disappears. We needed to have contrast in the scene in order for the glass to look like glass. I was pulled off of the environment for a week or so while the client, director and supervisors all worked out what they thought the environment should be. I was put on the task of creating the cubes and their glass shaders. At first I went with a totally realistic approach. I modeled all the sides of the glass cubes and stuck them up against each other. I put a realistic glass shader on them and hit render. Now I've never seen an actual 9x9x9 glass rubix cube before so I was a little suprised at first to find that the center of the cube was very dark. It was like the light just couldn't penetrate into the glass. I made the glass totally transparent and fresnel reflection at 100%, but it still had the same problem. The only way to make the center of the glass not get dark was to reduce the IOR for reflections and refractions. So I started breaking reality and it was starting to look better. After I had something kinda working I started adding a slight bump map near the edges of the cubes because I noticed in my glass reference on my desk that towards the corners the glass was warped a bit when the pieces were fused together. As soon as I did this it became aparent that with as many refractions as we needed you couldn't see through the cube again. Parts just became invisible inside all the crazy refractions. Not only that, but the rendertime suffered an almost 200% increase.

Eventually the environment was sorted out again and because I have architecture experience I was taken off the cube glass set up and put back on environments. Another artist took over the glass set up and came up with some nice looking results that totally broke reality, but that didn't matter because it looked good. I worked on variation after variation on the environment nearly right up until it delivered. At one point we finally decided that there wasn't going to be a good way to make the artificial lighting look good. We ripped open some holes in the ceiling and I was told to light the thing naturally. I think that was the best decision we made on the job, it really changed the look of the project and finally it was working.

In the meantime the other lighter who took over the cubes was getting creative with ways to reduce the rendertimes and still get great results. He came up with a great solution, but unfortunatly it was very complex. It was still faster than just waiting for frames though. His solution was to render the parts all by themselves without any glass in the scene. We did this three times. Once with an HDR generated from the actual 3d environment I built. A second time with an HDR of a studio lighting setup, and finally a third that only had a big area light above the parts. Our compositors would blend these three passes together over the environment background render until the parts looked cool. Then they would render an un-premultiplied pass of the parts back out for the lighters. The lighters took that pass into our cubes scenes and projection mapped it from the shot camera back onto the parts. Then we deleted all lighting from the scene. Only the glass cubes and projection mapped parts. This was rendered with the HDR of the CG environment for reflections and refractions. We still needed the ability to render mattes for the compositors, so we had to make scenes that had everything black except the parts which were 100% illuminated white. We also did an extra pass which was just the connecting edges of the glass cubes. This pass was used to tint only the fused faces of the glass cubes to have a greenish hue.